Elijah Craig Small Batch bottle

Elijah Craig Small Batch

Small-batch bourbon with vanilla bean, sweet fruit, oak, spice, smoke, and mint.

Suggested pour

Region
Kentucky Straight Bourbon
ABV
47%
Age
No age statement
Price
£38 - £45 | Mid-shelf gift

Why I would pour this when bourbon needs backbone

Elijah Craig Small Batch is the bourbon I would reach for when Buffalo Trace feels too gentle and Woodford Double Oaked feels too sweet. It brings vanilla bean, sweet fruit, fresh mint, baking spice, smoke, nutmeg, caramel, oak, toasted nuts, and enough 47% strength to give the pour structure.

The useful thing here is balance between everyday and serious. It is not barrel proof, not rare, and not trying to be precious. But it has more oak, proof, and maturity of flavour than many soft entry bourbons, which makes it a good step-up bottle for someone beginning to care about American whiskey.

I would use it for Father's Day, Thanksgiving, housewarmings, or a promotion gift for a bourbon drinker. It can handle an Old Fashioned, but it also has enough shape to drink neat without feeling like a cocktail-only bottle.

A sturdy small-batch bourbon with enough oak and proof to feel like a proper step up.

Nose

Vanilla bean, sweet fruit, fresh mint, spice, smoke, nutmeg, and oak.

Palate

Warm oak, caramel, baking spice, vanilla, toasted nuts, cocoa, and orchard fruit.

Finish

Long, sweet, slightly toasty, and warming at 94 proof.

In the glass

A reliable small-batch bourbon for drinkers who want more structure than the gentlest bottles.

Worth knowing

It is not as polished as premium wheated bourbon, but the extra oak and proof are the point.

Value verdict

Strong value when the price is close to the usual market range.

Comparable bottles

Also compare Buffalo Trace Bourbon, Four Roses Single Barrel, and Woodford Reserve Double Oaked.

Best-fit occasions

5 matches

Alternatives to compare

Back to vault
Ardbeg 10 Year Old bottle

Islay Single Malt

Ardbeg 10 Year Old

The 'Peat Monster' with a hidden heart of lemon and lime sweetness.

Buffalo Trace Bourbon bottle

Kentucky, USA Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Buffalo Trace Bourbon

The quintessential versatile Bourbon: vanilla, spice, and deep caramel.

Hibiki Harmony bottle

Japan Blended Japanese Whiskey

Hibiki Harmony

Japanese artistry in a bottle: floral, balanced, and incredibly elegant.

SuggestedWhiskey is editorial-first. Retailer links may earn a commission. This site is for adults of legal drinking age; enjoy whiskey responsibly.

Read disclosure